The arm race on cyber security makes protecting Internet resources harder and harder. In the past, DDoS was mostly on Layer 3 and Layer 4 but reports from various sources identified Layer 7 DDoS is the prevalent threat.
The slide below from Radware explains the changes in new DDoS trend. While protection on network traffic flooding is mature, attacker shift target to application layer.
As DDoS attack evolves and now is targeting application layer, the responsibility to protect web application is not only rest on the shoulder of CISO or network security team. It is time for web application architects to go to the front line. This article will analyse Layer 7 DDoS attacks and discuss some measures web application architects could deploy to mitigate impacts.
Types of Layer 7 DDoS Attack
A study conducted by Arbor Network showed that while attacks on DNS and SMTP exist, the most prevalent attack vector is still on HTTP.
Layer 7 DDoS attack is usually targeting the landing page of website or a specific URL. If an attacker successfully consume the either the bandwidth or OS resources (like socket) of the target, normal users are not able to access these resources.
A closer look at the targeted web resources
When developing protection strategy for website against Layer 7 DDoS attacks, we need to understand not all webpage are created equal. Diagram 1 shows different types of web pages. There are two ways to classify webserver resources: one is based on their access rights, the other is based on their content type.
When the content is for registered users, usually there is a user authentication process which prevents unauthenticated HTTP request. Pages only accessible by authenticated users are usually not the target of DDoS attack unless the attacker pre-registered a large number of user accounts and also automated the login process.
The login page which usually uses HTTPS is another websever resource that will be exploited by DDoS attackers since HTTPS handshaking is a high loading process for webserver. Public accessible content has higher risk of HTTP Flooding. The impact of HTTP Flooding is different depends on the content type.
Over load these resources for a long period of time would mean the DDoS attack is successful. On the other hand, DDoS attack on static web page usually impacts the outbound bandwidth and web server resources (like http connection pool, socket, memory and CPU). Dynamic pages will generate backend database queries and it has impact on the application server and database server.
Those types with red word are facing a higher risk of DDoS attack.
In the above paragraphs, we established a general understanding of Layer 7 DDoS attacks on different types of web resources. Below is a discussion on how to minimize the DDoS attack impact and lower the impact of website users.
These steps do not replace Layer 3 and 4 DDoS defenses and traffic filtering. However, unless your website is designed with these principles in mind, a carefully crafted Layer 7 DDoS attack could also bring down your website.
Protecting the Static Page
The most effective and also expensive way to protect static page against DDoS attack is buying services from a reputable Content Delivery Network (CDN). However, cost to run whole website on CDN may add up to a large sum. An alternative is to make uses of cloud platforms and distribute graphics, flash and JS files to one or more web servers located in another network. This method is already practiced by most high traffic web site which has dedicated server used for delivering images only.
Nowadays, most webpage sizes are over 100k bytes when all graphic, CSS and JS are loaded. Using the LOCI DDoS tool, it can easily consume all the bandwidth and web server CPU resources. In a HTTP GET Flood attack, both inbound link and outbound link will become a bottleneck.
A Web developer could not do much on managing the inbound traffic, however there are ways to lower the risk of outbound link becoming a bottleneck when under DDoS attack. Web architect should monitor the inbound/outbound traffic ratio for web server network interfaces.
One simple way to increase website defense against HTTP GET flooding attack is to store images and other large size media files in another sever (either within the same data centre or in another data centre).
By using another web server for delivering non-HTML static content, it helps to lower the both the CPU loading and also bandwidth consumption of the main web site. This method is similar to creating a DIY CDN. The cloud platforms and on-demand charging scheme is a excellent resources for deploying this solution.
Since the graphic files are public accessible, placing on a public cloud platform will not increase data security risk. Although this is a simple solution for static page, there are a few points to note. First, in the HTML code the “height” and “width” attribute of each image should be defined. This will ensure user see a proper screen layout even when the image server is inaccessible.
Secondly, when choosing a cloud platform it is best to find one that does not share the same upstream connectivity provider as your primary data centre. When DDoS attack happens, a good architecture should eliminate performance bottleneck as much as possible.
Protecting the Dynamic Page
Dynamic pages are generated based on user input and it involves business logic at application server and data queries at database server. If the web application displays large amount of data or accept user upload media files, an attacker could easily write a script and generate a large number of legitimate requests and consume both bandwidth and CPU power.
DDoS defenses mechanism relies on filtering out malicious traffic via pattern recognition will not be much useful if the attack target this weakness in dynamic pages. It is the web application developer responsibility to identify high risk web pages and develop mitigation measures to prevent DDoS attack
As displaying large amount of data based on user input is getting popular, web architects should develop strategy to prevent misuses of high loading webpage, particularly when it is publicly available.
One way is to make uses a form-specific cookie and verify the HTTP request is submitted from a valid HTML form. The steps would be
- When the browser loads a HTML form, the web server set a cookie specific to this form. When user click on the submit button, a cookie is also set in the HTTP request.
- When the web server process user request, the server side logic first check if a cookie is properly set before processing the user request.
- If the cookie does not exist or value not correct, the server side logic should forward the request to a landing page that displaying a URL link points to the HTML form.
Below diagram show the logical flow.
The principle of this method is to establish an extra checking before executing the server side logic supporting the dynamic page, thus preserving CPU resources at the application server and database server.
Most DDoS attacking tools has simple HTTP functions and is not able to process cookies. When using Wireshark to capture HTTP request from LOIC DDoS attack tool, the packets show that LOIC does not accept cookie from web sites. The similar result is obtained from HOIC tool.
DDoS attacker may record this cookie and send out this cookie within the attack traffic, which could be easily done using a script. To compensate this, this form specific cookie should be changed regularly or following a triggering logic.
Please read more about :
This article only shows some ways web architects could use and add DDoS defense into the DNA of web application. The methods described will increase a web application ability to survive a HTTP Flooding attacks. When attacks are more application specific, web architects should start take on DDoS defense responsibility and design systems that both secure and scalable.
1 thought on “Layer 7 DDoS Attack : A Web Architect Perspective”
Pingback: Design a hack proof password storage - A-INFOSEC